(urth) Typee, incidentally
Gerry Quinn
gerryq at indigo.ie
Sat Nov 13 12:12:16 PST 2010
From: "David Stockhoff" <dstockhoff at verizon.net>
> In other words, the Hierodules treat Urth like an island of savages, and
> their "uplifting" efforts are not too different from the "missionary work"
> that corrupts and enslaves the islanders, in Melville's view. If this is
> not immediately apparent, perhaps is it partly because we are not
> accustomed to seeing ourselves as the savages in a colonial situation.
I'm not convinced - the Commonwealth may be bad, but the country of the
Ascians would appear to be worse. If Urthlings are corrupted and enslaved
by the Hierodules, it is more down to earlier actions i.e. the introduction
of a black hole into the Sun. And the Ascians seem to be worse enslaved by
the undersea powers.
Of course you can if you want wrap up the current business and the earlier
chastising of Urth as a combination of missionary work and more direct
colonisation/subjugation. Or, if you like, the mission is the whole purpose
of the colonisation - Urth is not the source of farmland, or spices, or
slaves.
I tend towards the view that the Hierodules are on the right side in the
Cosmic struggle; if they were merely human we could indeed be very
suspicious of their motives, but I do not think they are intended to be. Of
course, that is just what one of theire dupes would be expected to think,
but still... as I noted before, we haven't seen anything at all to make us
think the other side is good.
- Gerry Quinn
More information about the Urth
mailing list