(urth) Wolfe at the Beach: Two Reviews

Rex Lycanthrosaurus lycanthrosaurus at fastmail.fm
Tue Aug 28 17:36:45 PDT 2007

Apologies to both mantis and Peter Wright if "errors" was deliberate and
a puckish attempt at humor. I thought for sure from the phrasing and
context that "errors" had been substituted for "entries." My bad.

As for Nick Gever's gentle counter-assertion that there are indeed sfnal
elements in the book, he's right, but they play such an insubstantial
part in the narrative, that Pirate Freedom would be no different without
them. I still certainly have my doubts about the book being "Fantasy"
although oddly enough I'll probably vote for Gibson's Spook Country as
being one of my top sf novels for the year.

One should also keep in mind that Gene Wolfe is a writer of consummate
grace, regardless of marketing categories.

> I forwarded Rex's post to mantis, who wrote:
> >Right.  Well, given the context, I share Rex's pain at typos--from 
> >both sides (reader and publisher), or more sides, if possible.
> >
> >Setting that aside, the "blunder" attributed to Wright is actually 
> >100% accurate.  That is, I said it, or wrote it, and he is repeating 
> >it verbatim, with perhaps too straight a face.
> mantis went on to add:
> >Again, I understand how he could have taken it as a blunder since he 
> >was being irritated by real typos, so I'm not being critical of Rex. 
> >And I can also see how a self-deprecating remark given by myself 
> >might lose humor when repeated by another, and even seem deprecating 
> >or condescending (if not a flat out blunder).
> >
> >=Michael=
  Rex Lycanthrosaurus
  lycanthrosaurus at fastmail.fm

http://www.fastmail.fm - One of many happy users:

More information about the Urth mailing list