(urth) Urth Digest, Vol 110, Issue 10‏

Marc Aramini marcaramini at yahoo.com
Fri Oct 11 05:08:14 PDT 2013


Of course there is time travel or the rajan and Oreb would not show up in the past stories so frequently as themselves so obviously. Before they go to Urth the first time the narrator imagines Green before the corruption hit.  It kind of befuddles me how a series with time travel all over the place and the bending of light, time, and space in its earliest entries suddenly wouldn't involve it in its final iterations. 

The narrators don't know what's going on in Short Sun- they don't know who they are or where they are.  Looking at the sky they are lost. 


Sent from my iPhone

On Oct 11, 2013, at 4:54 AM, Lee Berman <severiansola at hotmail.com> wrote:

> .Andreas Johansson: Was going to ask also about the chronological work-out between 
>> the Whorl and Urth, since Typhon's reign seems to be much more than three centuries 
>> past from Severian's age (if the astral projection to Urth isn't a time travel as well), 
>> but then I realized: time dilation & relativity. Ship time doesn't equal planet time - who 
>> knows how long the Whorl was really out there, and how far they've travelled?
> 
> Yes, among those who scour the text for timeline clues, many arrive at a figure of around
> 1000 years of age for the Commonwealth, so Typhon's reign was at least that much earlier
> than Severian's time.
> 
> Moreover, at the end of RTTW, Hoof comments that some Typhonian artifact on Urth 
> (the Red Sun Whorl) seems older than 300 years, and SilkHorn confirms that it is,
> indeed much older. Time dilation seems a likely explanation to me.
> 
>> Typhon sent the Whorl to colonize another planet, seems reasonable that he should send it to 
>> a planet that resembles a pristine Urth...
> 
>> ...And come to think of it, Urthlings in our deep future/Severian's deep past travelled all across 
>> the galaxy, right? Are Horn & the other whorlings necessary the first humans to reach Blue & Green?
> 
> In BotNS it is implied that the human race expanded out from Urth and changed/evolved. So some,
> (perhaps all) of the alien "cacogens" are really evolved humans who have returned to their
> planet of origin.  Thus B, F and O start with ill-fitting human masks which reveal horrific
> faces underneath. But when the horrific masks are removed, faces of superhuman beauty are
> revealed.
> 
> So, perhaps The Neighbors had a human origin?
> 
> Some wonder whether Typhon had his origin on Blue and was using the Whorl to send human worshippers
> (tribute of fair women and boys?) back to his home planet.  Perhaps also back to the "Mother"?. 
> 
> (The "Mother" representing Echidna in some fashion, the mythological Echidna being the "Mother
> Of All Monsters" while her mate Typhon was the "Father Of All Monsters". We do see electronic Echidna
> having a zest for human sacrifice in Long Sun and The Mother on Blue enjoying drowned sailors.)                         
> _______________________________________________
> Urth Mailing List
> To post, write urth at urth.net
> Subscription/information: http://www.urth.net



More information about the Urth mailing list