(urth) Like a good Neighbor

[David Stockhoff]

On 11/22/2011 8:19 AM, Lee Berman wrote:
>> Marc Aramini: Don't you remember the literary technique Severian talked about?
>> A torturer paid by one side to make it quick, the other to make it painful, and
>> by positioning them just right, he succeeds - thus does Wolfe speak of narrative
>
> I agree fully, Marc. I have used the old/young woman optical illusion and the
> House Absolute/Secret House as analogies for the same principle. It is to no avail
> for some people. They are exclusionary readers and for them there is one and only
> one best answer and once determined, it excludes the possibility of multiple meaning.
>
> "GREEN is Urth!!!" (I think that is the proper quote, caps to designate BLUE is not Urth).
> Marc I think you recognize there is metaphorical meaning in that. But you also find
> literal meaning. Why can't it be both, depending on which perspective you are taking in
> regard to space, time and dreams.
>
> Likewise this pointless debate on whether Horn died in the pit. If there is a tranferrable
> soul being considered, the definition of death is no longer as cut and tried as we, in
> our world, define it. Why can't Horn be dead in one way of looking at things and not really
> dead from another perspective. Moreover, why can't it be recognized that Wolfe writes in
> a way in which both can be true?
>
>> Sergei Soloviev: As I explain, it is one of many ends. And I think the reading is richer
>> if you do not see maximal "yes" or maximal "no" on any occasion.
>
> Sergei, I think you are on the right track. But you are trying to compromise and thus losing
> something on both ends. If we are trying to understand our own human existence, the concept
> of yes or no is needed. Either yes, someone is alive or no, they are not. But if we are
> trying to understand God, that is too limiting. Jesus is both dead AND alive. God is both
> maximal yes AND maximal no.
>
> This is what makes Gene Wolfe a special author. He is simultaneously trying to explore
> human existence and an understanding of the divine. We shouldn't ignore either one of these. 		 	   		

Osiris was both living AND dead, and that's why he became king of the 
underworld.