(urth) Like a good Neighbor
David Stockhoff
dstockhoff at verizon.net
Sun Nov 20 06:41:33 PST 2011
On 11/20/2011 9:36 AM, Gerry Quinn wrote:
> *From:* António Pedro Marques <mailto:entonio at gmail.com>
>
> Having read as far as the chapter ‘Krait’, the idea that he was
> replaced by a Neighbour in the pit seems bizarre to me. Just consider
> the most obvious point: he needs the help of an inhumu to get out! And
> to get it he betrays his wife and family. Unless you think this
> Neighbour is a spy for his race and a rather nasty piece of work, or a
> very impulsive and impulsive creature with no conscience, how do you
> explain this?
So what? You'll have to outline your objection a little better. When
does a Wolfe character ever take complete moral responsibility for
everything? What do the Neighbors owe him after unkilling him?
> The ‘glittering eyes’ he sees while lying semi-conscious, and the
> ‘long nosed man or spider’ that he apparently sees with his eyes
> closed are presumably Neighbours. [Are we supposed to think of
> Severian? Doesn’t make much sense for him to be there though.] The
> long-nosed man seemingly uses a device on him that sends him on a
> short astral excursion. I think it is likely that this device
> *changed* him in some way by granting him or causing him to develop
> certain psychic abilities (they probably developed as a consequence of
> his temporary exposure as well as subsequent experimentation and other
> events). But he is still Horn.
> Assuming the Neighbours were present and are essentially benevolent,
> it seems they could not help him in the obvious way, i.e. by getting
> him out of the pit, as Krait did. But this ties in very well with the
> notion that they are half-in, half-out of our dimension, and are
> limited in their physical abilities (see also the corpses in the sewer
> on Green).
As fairies always are.
More information about the Urth
mailing list