(urth) Pike's ghost

James Wynn crushtv at gmail.com
Tue Nov 29 09:19:01 PST 2011


On 11/29/2011 11:09 AM, António Pedro Marques wrote:
> Now for something completely different (really). Who is (are?) the 
> Silk in the Rajan?
>
> - Has the original Silk been lost?
> - No Silk we meet seems to know anything about the 20 years of Silk's 
> life after Horn left the Whorl.

Obviously, I believe that Wolfe has created a narrator for these stories 
who, while writing in first-person, is analogous to Horn and Nettle 
writing about Silk.

> - At the end of RW we simultaneously learn how 'a' Silk may or may 
> have not been hiding in Pig, and how 'Silk' accepts he is Silk in New 
> Viron. 

That's not my interpretation of the final events at all.

> However, the two episodes have no connection between them. The 'Silk 
> in denial' we meet, except for the bit aboard the Whorl, is all after 
> the appearance of the Silk in Pig. Which Silk is the one in Pig? Does 
> he or does he not get into the [then yet to be] Rajan?

It is an interesting question as to whether Silver Silk has possessed 
the Rajan.




More information about the Urth mailing list