(urth) Like a good Neighbor

[Gerry Quinn]

From: Marc Aramini 

> In theory, I don't mind Gerry's skepticism; everyone has their roles.  
> 
> Yet the weirdest accusation was leveled at me today when Wolfe's 
> grocery list came up today: that I would turn potatoes into a left handed s
> ocket wrenches.  But Gene DID write me a very simple three word sentence
>  that is a noun, a linking verb, and a predicate nominative, and I, contrary 
> to that accusation, was the only person in the universe to take it at face 
> value instead of taking it as some engineering joke, a metaphor, etc.  I 
> feel like hard nosed metaphorical dismissal of evidence is more like 
> turning a potato into something else - not what I do.  I believe in symbols 
> of course, but those symbols are something more than just useless metaphor, 
> they can be applied to shape character with their hard, defining edges.
A little joke, and not directed just as you. 
There would have to be a spot on the paper that if you looked closely seemed like a left-handed can-opener.  That’s how you’d know the potatoes were just misdirection and trickery.


> Don't you remember the literary technique Severian talked about?  A torturer 
> paid by one side to make it quick, the other to make it painful, and by positioning
>  them just right, he succeeds - thus does Wolfe speak of narrative, and I see it 
> on this board, (until time holds my own severed head up for inspection.)

A nice metaphor – but I’m not trying to torture you, Marc.  I just don’t think the books support the notion that inhumi are vegetables.

- Gerry Quinn


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.urth.net/pipermail/urth-urth.net/attachments/20111122/dc348ec0/attachment-0003.htm>