(urth) Serpents and Undines
Jeff Wilson
jwilson at io.com
Sat Jul 31 20:42:27 PDT 2010
On 7/31/2010 1:03 PM, David Stockhoff wrote:
> I wonder, given the way Vodalus talks, if his path isn't almost the
> better one. He speaks of the sun hiding the stars that are our proper
> heritage, of how his masters wait until humanity is purified, and how
> vile are the actions of the Autarch.
>
> So although, yes, one side is nominally "white" and the other nominally
> "black" (as Vodalus himself puts it), the outcome seems pretty win-win,
> or equal parts lose-lose. Is it surprising the undines help Severian and
> Erebus/Abaia don't kill him? Doesn't Vodalus win when Severian is on the
> throne, and is not the Commonwealth thus defeated and occupied?
Vodalus fails in his ambition to upset the rule of the Autarch and put
the Exultants in charge. The rest of the counter-changed patchwork of
good deeds by evil forces and misfortunes at the hands of the righteous
is the inevitable consequence of created existence, selectively played
up by Vodalus to propagandize the uncommitted.
It's basic Qabbalism that in every good thing on earth there is some
evil, but likewise some good can come of any evil act, and this
"impurity" is in fact vital to give things balance and what we call
tropisms today. The renewed sun does hide the stars, yes, but only
during the day, they remain visbile at night as is proper, and their
limited accessibility makes them all the more precious for their use in
navigation, time-keeping, and divination. To serve the good at the cost
of evil and misfortune is part of what gives it value; if to help others
had an immediate prospect of repayment in kind it wouldn't be kindness
so much as commerce, which is why kindness to animals was seen as the
higher virtue, without hope of reward.
--
Jeff Wilson - jwilson at io.com
IEEE Student Chapter Blog at
< http://ieeetamut.org >
More information about the Urth
mailing list