jwilson at io.com
Sat Jul 31 02:41:04 PDT 2010
On 7/31/2010 3:01 AM, Lee Berman wrote:
>> Jeff Wilson- This could be from duty and from a hope of redemption, that they can
>> continue to serve the cause of Urth, instead of ending in failure. And it
>> could be some projection on Sev's part, relieved that he didn't become a
>> puppet of the dozens of imperious minds of his predecessors. It's his
>> glands that are still real, after all. Something in the process may keep the
>> duplicated personalities amiable to the situation, the way the Casdoe's husband's
>> imprint wasn't upset or particularly concerned about having been eaten or helping
>> the alzabo kill and eat the rest of his family.
> I think this is a very apt comparison which I haven't seen made before.
> I can't help but think that horror was intended in the scene where Becan is so
> immediately happy and accepting of his new existence as chunks of chewed meat in the
> Alzabo digestive system and as a (presumably) temporary neural circuit that he is
> willingly desirous that his family join him in the belly of the beast.
I agree, the horror of not-rightness is very strong when the beast firs
speaks in the little girl's voice. But horror eventually gives way to
reasoning that it must be that way, or the victim's unalterted attitude
would hinder it to the point of suicide or starvation. This corruption
of the victim's personhood is partly why I don't consider the remnant
memories a survival of the original victim any more than any other
record or memory of their living existence.
> Yet under similar circumstances we are supposed to interpret rapture instead of
> horror for the beings living on in Severian? I just don't know. Perhaps it is meant
> to be an individual interpretation. But my impression is that for Thecla and for the
> others in Severian's head it isn't a divine experience. At best they all remain
> lonely and unfulfilled. We don't hear much from them in UotNS.
I'm having cognitive dissonance with the objective use of "they" and
their experiences. The imprint of each mind is associated with the
individual, but it doesn't correspond one for one with them. Each hand
has the whole life, after all, so they can't both be the individual. We
might call them dividuals, or multiplicuals.
Whatever "they" are, I don't think they are meant to have a truly
objective identity and feelings apart from Severian, any more than the
aquastors have from their Yesodi controllers. Maybe an eidolon, which
has to be reconstructed with as perfect fidelity to the original as
possible, would count as "an" objective person, if not the same
Jeff Wilson - jwilson at io.com
IEEE Student Chapter Blog at
< http://ieeetamut.org >
More information about the Urth