(urth) academic commentary

[Matthew Weber]

I think it's in *God in the Dock *where Lewis refers to this argumentative
fallacy as "Bulverism".

On Wed, Dec 1, 2010 at 1:55 PM, James Wynn <crushtv at gmail.com> wrote:

>
>  Dan'l Danehy-Oakes wrote-
> Thus, while your first statement is necessary it is not sufficient: it
> is legitimate, and perhaps even necessary, to ask why <critic> chooses
> the methodology s/he does and not some other methodology. The answer
> to that question is going to be rooted in <critic>'s ideology and
> metaphysics.
>
>
> Analyzing an argument by the supposed motives of the arguer can quickly go
> off the rails.
>
> From "Pilgrim's Regress" by CS Lewis:
>
> "'Come, come,' said the jailor. "You must know your catechism by now. You,
> there' (and he pointed to a prisoner little older than a boy whose name was
> Master Parrot), 'what is argument?'
>
> 'Argument,' said Master Parrot, 'is the attempted rationalization of the
> arguer's desires.'
>
> 'Very good,' replied the jailor, 'but you should turn out your toes and put
> your hands behind your back. That is better. Now: what is the proper answer
> to an argument proving the existence of the Landlord? The proper answer is,
> 'You say that because you are a Steward'.
>
> 'Good boy. But hold your head up. That's right. And what is the answer to
> an argument proving that Mr. Phally's songs are just as brown as Mr.
> Halfways?'
>
> 'There are two only generally necessary to damnation', said master Parrot.
> 'The first is, "You say that because you are a Puritan," and the second is,
> "You say that because you are a sensualist." '
>
> 'Good. Now just one more. What is the answer to an argument turning on the
> belief that two and two make four?'
>
> 'The answer is, "You say that because you are a mathematician." '
>
> 'You are a very good boy,' said the jailor. "
>
>
> u+16b9
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Urth Mailing List
> To post, write urth at urth.net
> Subscription/information: http://www.urth.net
>



-- 
Matt +

No one knows what he can do till he tries.
    Publilius Syrus (First century B.C.), Maxim 786
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.urth.net/pipermail/urth-urth.net/attachments/20101201/161236af/attachment-0002.htm>