(urth) Suzanne Delage redux
gerryq at indigo.ie
Tue Dec 7 22:05:58 PST 2010
From: "Gwern Branwen" <gwern0 at gmail.com>
> On Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 11:15 PM, Gwern Branwen <gwern0 at gmail.com> wrote:
>> So, someone complained it was quiet around here...
>> To rectify that, I'd like to offer up a little experiment of mine.
>> This is sort of an attempt at what I think a wiki article on Wolfe
>> stories could look like: the story or a detailed summary, followed by
>> analysis of allusions, and then a summing up of the theories floated
>> on Urth.net and hopefully a dispassionate appraisal. I doubt this
>> format would scale to the novels, but it seems to work well in this
> I recently gave it another polish and put it on my website:
> Hopefully this form is much more readable. I don't think I missed any
> major theories about "Suzanne Delage" but perhaps someone has thought
> of a new one in the last year or so?
I believe I have an explanation of the story, which falls close to the
category of 'Missed Chances' in your list,.but the link there from Alice
Turner does not really hit the target. I'm pretty sure of this explanation,
so Lee and James may feel free to line up the slings and arrow! Here it is:
Suzanne Delage is a kind of horror story, but the supernatural element is
something we do not think of as supernatural, because it is the stuff of
every romance novel - only Wolfe has inverted the story. The element is as
follows: there is one person who is made for us, and when we meet them we
will fall in love, perhaps have to overcome some vicissitudes, but
eventually live happily ever after.
The key to it is near the beginning, in the paragraph that starts: "When I
had switched off the light I lay recalling, very pleasantly on the whole, my
life. It has been a pleasant life, though I fear a dull, and perhaps a
So might a goose nailed to the floor of a foie gras forcing pen describe its
life, if it were philosophically inclined, and determined to look on the
bright side of things. This man's life is empty and blighted. Why?
Because by some perverse operation of chance, he has never met his other
half, the woman he is made to love. (Does the converse apply to Suzanne? I
do not know. Perhaps her life works okay both ways.)
At the end after "the usual half teasing reproaches about my (supposed) gay
bachelor life" he sees and is enchanted by Suzanne's daughter, who is (we
are told) the image of Suzanne at the age when he should have met her.
There is no auctorial duplicity here. She is indeed the daughter, not
Suzanne, and she is indeed the image of Suzanne. The description is
deliberately sensuous in regard to her body "the virginal breasts half
afraid to press the soft angora of her sweater, nor the little waist I might
have circled with my two hands", and also refers to her spirit "vivacity
coupled with an innocence and intelligence that were hers alone". There is
no doubt here - this is the image of the woman he would have loved. If only
he had met her.
By some perverse conspiracy of chance or fate he did not, and his life has
- Gerry Quinn
More information about the Urth