(urth) Grand Unified Theory
James Wynn
crushtv at gmail.com
Wed Aug 25 08:50:18 PDT 2010
>> Wynn - The word "typhoon" comes from "Typhon" -- not that it would
>> prevent
>> Wolfe from associating the two anyway if he wanted to.
>
> Marques - That's actually open to question.
> - _Typhon_ is an english spelling pronunciation of greek <tu'fwn>,
> which would be more or less 'two FAWN' [tu'fO:n] if read 'correctly'.
> - _typhoon_ is an english transcription of [tai'fun], from some
> language spoken along the margins of the Indic ocean.
>
> Even if one posits that [tai'fun] is ultimately from the greek, one
> still would have to explain how did greek [tu] become [tai]. The
> english [ai] is merely from the english great vowel shift compounded
> with a misreading of greek <y> as [i], which it never was. Had english
> gotten the word by natural borrowing, rather than in misread written
> form centuries after, it wouldn't have [ai].
>
> Not impossible, but unlikely.
Well, I'm not a linguist so I can't begin to break it down. But each
language has it's own special tendencies to change over time. And the
vowels change the fastest. The most common etymology I have read is that
"typhon" came to Hindi through Parsi in order to become "typhoon". So
there's a lot of room for mischief in there. But I'm sure you are right
that there are alternate assertions by people who know a lot more about
it than me. Still, the spellings and meanings are similar enough that I
have no doubt Wolfe would happily associate them even if he knew for a
fact that the words had no real etymological connection.
u+16b9
More information about the Urth
mailing list