(urth) Re: Crush on trial
Chris
rasputin_ at hotmail.com
Wed Mar 23 22:08:34 PST 2005
I too thought that was a great reference, and brings into even sharper
contrast Severian's choice. And I think Crush's words here are revealing of
something, though I am hesitant to assert exactly what it means. Sev is a
surgeon for Urth, for his "world". This "world" is not equatable with the
people on it (almost all of them die) or their future generations (because
they could just as easily be born on another world, though the proportion
may or may not be exactly the same). He is not saving his "race", because
humans already exist elsewhere in the universe and, ultimately, the form of
life that comes to dominate the rejuvenated world may be human-descended but
is not necessarily "human" as we'd understand the term. What is Severian
saving? We could try to answer with a name, "Urth", but even the *name*
changes (and if name-changes are suggestive of anything, they are
suggestions that the named entity being referred to has changed).
The fact that the answer to this question ("What is Severian saving?")
seemed so clear, and yet becomes so murky when we try to focus on it, to me
indicates that there is more to our intuitive understanding of BotNS than we
are commonly aware of.
In a side note, I've had a bizarre afternoon. Out of 4 papers I saw
presented today, all four mentioned torture and 3 of them explicitly used
the term "torturer" - despite there being little to no reason for that
subject to even come up. (2 were on abortion, 1 on character issues, and 1
on addiction). Synchronicity...
-- Civet
>But Sev CAN objectively analyze both outcomes. He's not a Stalin, Hitler,
>or Ozymandias killing multitudes to remake the world according to some
>vision in their own minds. He's a surgeon performing triage on a dying
>world.
>
>~ Crush
More information about the Urth
mailing list